Top Rated Auto Insurance Companies

top rated companies
It is important to look into the financial stability of a carrier to choose a top rated auto insurance company. The financial strength of a carrier will reinforce its ability to pay out claims. An unstable insurer may be susceptible to bankruptcy; therefore, leading to unpaid claims. Independent rating agencies such as AM Best give each a letter grade that determines its financial strength.  

Compare quotes from top rated car insurance companies:

Zip Code: 
currently insured:yesno
Rating scale used by AM Best:
  • A++ and A+ (Superior) = superior ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • A and A- (Excellent) = excellent ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • B++ and B+ (Good) = good ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • B and B- (Fair) = fair ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • C++ and C+ (marginal) = marginal ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • C and C- (weak) = weak ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders
  • D (poor) = weak ability to meet their ongoing obligations to policyholders

OnlineAutoInsurance.com only sells B+ and greater top rated auto insurance companies to ensure customer satisfaction.  Click on each logo to find out more about the top 10 companies represented below:

21st CenturyGMACInfinityCarnegie GeneralUnitrin
Bristol WestWestern GeneralWestern UnitedAccess GeneralExplorer

It is important to know what kind of coverage is needed, ways to find savings and the way insurers determine premiums when comparing the best providers. Be sure to learn more about the auto insurance companies which participate in rate comparisons.


Questions about Evaluating Car Insurance Cos.

  • How Do I Find a Top Auto Insurance Company in Massachusetts?

    Massachusetts skylineWhen it comes to choosing an auto insurance company, Massachusetts motorists have many different options. But not all policy providers can offer the same rates or quality of service, so, to find a top rated insurer, residents need to shop around. Making comparisons online can...

  • What's a Good Auto Insurance Company Rating?

    Letter gradesAn important step in purchasing an auto insurance policy is to make sure that the coverage is coming from a provider that can be counted on. Those who are familiar with a certain carrier may feel safe in dealing with them, but in states with dozens of...

  • How Do I Choose the Right Maryland Auto Insurance Company?

    Maryland drawn on a chalkboardIn Maryland there are hundreds of coverage providers that are licensed to sell auto insurance. Choosing one of the best insurers, however, requires drivers to research as many options as possible and make comparisons. Motorists should evaluate not only the...

News Related to Auto Insurance Company Rankings

  • Recent Recovery Reports Highlight Usefulness of Insurance Reviews

    February 10, 2012 - Recent reports showing that regulators in California, Michigan, Georgia, Montana, Ohio and North Carolina together recovered nearly $150 million last year on behalf of consumers who had been wronged by coverage providers highlights the valuable insight shoppers can get by researching auto insurance reviews and complaint data online. A large portion of ...

  • GEICO Rate Filing to Save Calif. Consumers More Than $90 Million

    July 25, 2011 - Some California motorists who are insured by GEICO will save an average of $127 a year, thanks to a 10.7 percent drop in the company's auto policy rates announced Friday. "It is good news when consumers pay less for premiums and are able to keep more of their earnings," Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones said in a statement...

  • Insurance Regulators Recover Millions for Mo. Policyholders

    July 15, 2011 - The Missouri Department of Insurance has recovered $5.2 million for policyholders so far this year in disputes over claims involving tornado damage and other events, officials announced this week. Regulators received more than 8,600 inquiries in the second quarter of the year over a range of policy issues—with more than 1,100...

Articles on Researching Insurance Providers

  • Gender Matters: Why Men Pay More for Car Insurance

    May 10, 2012 - People strive for gender equality in most facets of life, but in the auto insurance world, it's a commonly known fact that men usually end up paying more. Data provided by California regulators, for example, shows...

  • Factors That Affect Car Insurance Rates

    May 07, 2012 - Coverage providers take a wide range of personal details into account when rating drivers, and as a result, the price of automobile insurance is different for...